Posted by: Jane | July 25, 2008

brain imaging research volunteer

Just a quick note for all those neurological and brain science researchers into meditation and manic depression.

I have a standing offer to volunteer for mri or pet imaging of my brain.

Why would you want to image my brain?

As a patient with untreated manic depression and schizophrenia my brain should be a wasteland. Studies apparently show that

Bipolar brains shrink

schizophrenic brains shrink

Bipolar brains have an unique chemical signature

Bipolars apparently have a genetic biomarker

schizophrenics apparently have a genetic biomarker

Family genetics

In 1991 my mother admitted to me during my second inpatient stay for suicide that she had suffered depression and suicidal ideation all her life.

In 1999, ten years after my dual diagnosis of manic depression and schizo affective my sister went inpatient on the opposite side of the country for a suicide attempt. She was diagnosed with Bipolar.

As we move through the year 2008 I look back on the fact that I have been depression, mania, self injury , voices and delusion free for over ten years.

How is this possible you might ask?

If you are familiar with my blog content and videos on youtube then you know how.

I secluded myself from other people with mental health issues and practiced meditation full time for years.

After the first year of that lifestyle I achieved a milestone marker of the first year without cyclical suicidal depression. Now over ten years have passed and I remain symptom free.

Some folks would not think breathing exercises and navel gazing could have that effect but that is because they are not up to date on the latest in meditation and brain imaging research.

1. Meditation is a way of tapping into a process of manipulating brain activity

2. Meditating does more than just feel good and calm you down, it makes you perform better — and alters the structure of your brain, researchers have found.

3. Brain research is beginning to produce concrete evidence for something that Buddhist practitioners of meditation have maintained for centuries: Mental discipline and meditative practice can change the workings of the brain and allow people to achieve different levels of awareness.

4. “Our data suggest that meditation practice can promote cortical plasticity in adults in areas important for cognitive and emotional processing and well-being,” says Sara Lazar, leader of the study and a psychologist at Harvard Medical School

5. New imaging technology makes it possible for scientists to document the brain activity of Buddhist monks. Dalai Lama visits MIT

6. In recent years, a group of neuroscientists are exploring the hypothesis that meditation can actually change the way the brain works.

7. scientists at the University of Wisconsin at Madison used new scanning techniques to examine brain activity in a group of Buddhists.Their tests revealed activity in the left prefrontal lobes of experienced Buddhist practitioners.This area is linked to positive emotions, self-control and temperament.Their tests showed this area of the Buddhists’ brains are constantly lit up and not just when they are meditating.

8. Medical effects of meditation.

So I make the following predictions. I must have these bipolar/schizoid biomarkers. I must have this unique bipolar brain signature. At 33 years old having had my first suicidal ideation nearly 25 years ago there must be some observable level of brain volume decrease.

Unless I have reversed that brain volume decrease. According to the meditation studies meditation builds the brain up increasing brain volume and density.

So we can make a few generalized conclusions.

Either meditation cured me of mental illness and there is no evidence in my brain whatsoever of the alleged brain destroying powers of bipolar and schizophrenia.

Or I still have these disorders and they are completely held in stasis by meditation.

Now either of those conclusions are medically and scientifically significant.

Meditation won’t put a dime in Big Pharma’s bank account but it is definitely important information to the ongoing study of psychology and perhaps psychiatry as well.

I make this offer. I am willing to submit to brain imaging while meditating and not meditating.

After 20 years of meditation experience I can make my brain light up the same way Tibetan and Buddhist Monks do I guarantee it.

I would also like to make a few other predictions or speculations about these brain images and biomarkers.

The first is this.

Biomarkers occur as a result of prolonged mental illness symptoms.

It is a correlation not a cause.

Biomarkers would eventually disappear if the symptoms went into remission long enough.

This is similar to the *chemical imbalance* theory.

Genetic chemical imbalances do not cause mental illness. The chemical imbalance is an effect of prolonged suffering of symptoms. Such chemical imbalances would restore themselves if the symptoms went into remission long enough.

Brain cell death and brain volume decreases associated with Bipolars and Schizoids are a result of the treatments for the illness, not the illness itself.

For Bipolars and Schizo that self medicate, the years of alcohol and drug abuse cause brain volume decreases.

For Bipolars and Schizoids that use polypharmacy the probable cause of this brain volume decrease is their meds more specifically neuroleptics.

That is not to say mental illness has no appreciable effect on brain volume.

There is the saying, if you don’t use it you lose it. Certainly if you fail to control or try to control your mental health symptoms then the natural brain functions that would instill stability become stunted and atrophy.

However in learning to manage mental illness symptoms without drugs I am guessing those areas of my brain are in reality much more developed than you might expect. Perhaps more developed than in those who never suffered from mental illness because it is an area of the brain I had to work at constantly to achieve stability and wellness.

My conclusions.

Biomarkers and chemical imbalances are the snapshot of ongoing mental illness. They are an effect of the illness, not a cause or a predictor. These imbalances and markers would disappear with remission of symptoms.

Bipolar Disorder and Schizophrenia do have a cure. Meditation is that cure. I think the MRI and PET scans will prove this unambiguously.

If you weigh the risk-reward ratio for taking five years out of your life in order to meditate until your emotional and cognitive controls are established. You compare that to a life spent with unmitigated mental health issues or a life spent on polypharmacy dependency than you will quickly realize that interrupting your career and lifestyle in order to cure your mental health problems permanently is more advantageous than a life spent keeping symptoms at bay with drugs while developing diabetes, obesity, tardives dyskinesia, nervous system ataxia, thyroid imbalances, kidney failure and psych med addiction.

Who is willing to take five years out of their life to meditate until they have inner peace?

Only the most eccentric, the most desperate and the most intelligent of people.

You have to have a certain level of foresight to see the benefits. Most people are too hung up trying to consume and move up Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs to slow down and do what it takes to make lasting changes in themselves.

They would rather pop a pill and keep on surfing the web than sit down by a river or in the silence of their bedroom and sit quietly until they have mastered their mental landscape. It is too much work to heal yourself. That and all the bullshit pharmaganda would have people believe that it is not possible and they don’t have anything to take responsibility for. (except getting that scrip filled right away!)

Big Pharma takes advantage of that and profits. People tell themselves it is worth it as long as the pills keep their credit lines active and roof over their head.

Another predication I make is that the mental illness reversing powers of meditation work better the younger you are when you start. The more severe the symptoms, the sooner you need to check out of life and meditate.

People in their 40s, 50s, 60s and beyond will have decades of inertia to overcome if they have been suffering all that time. There is a sad irony to that. Young people generally don’t take that kind of time off. They are too busy being beautiful and trying to be successful. It was mostly older folks I met in meditation circles.

People in their teens, 20s and 30s that take this work seriously can make huge leaps in mental health sanitation if they take stick with it.

The longer you go without meditation the harder it will be do reverse your mental illness with it.

Not to say it is impossible, just much more difficult. I started serious meditation at the age of 21 a year after my last suicide attempt. That may have made a major difference in my recovery.

In the meantime, I would like to see future imaging studies of the brain to include whether or not the subjects being imaged have been on meds, what meds those are and how long they have been on them

I want to see controls in these studies such as scans of brains of people with bipolar and schizophrenia that are not on meds at all and compare them to scans of people on meds. I want clarifications and more details about these brain shrinkage studies.

So to further the cause of science and psychology I offer myself for brain imaging studies as a meditator who has cured themselves of manic depression and schizophrenia. I am also willing to take the bipolar and schizophrenic biomarker tests at anytime.

Remember, if I have the biomarkers, than my symptom remission is scientifically valuable information

If I do not have these biomarkers while my sister continues to receive treatment for bipolar and my mother continues to go without it than this too is scientifically significant.

Gene expression is an interesting thing. Stress, hormones, sickness and health all turn genes off or on. My guess is that gene expression for mental illness is not set in stone but is merely a snapshot of the current situation, not a reason or a predictor but an effect.

My contact information is on my Home page


Responses

  1. I would be interested myself in what my brain scans currently look like vs. what they looked like while I was on lithium and lamictal.
    I have a feeling there was reduced activity, but that it was mainly due to the drugs and also my self-reinforced negative behaviors.
    But I’ll never really know.

  2. What don’t you miss the apparent brain building powers of lithium?

  3. I can’t help it, there’s something about these studies that reminds me of those that showed SSRIs to be sooo effective… What is it, that we don’t know about how exactly these studies were conducted?

    Not so long ago, I somewhere read that neither lithium nor any other “mood-stabilizer” ever have been proven to actually stabilize moods. Unfortunately, I failed to scribble down where it said this. I’ll let you know, if I find out.

  4. That is always good information to know.

    Personally i have always felt that a good portion of these wonderful experiences from psych meds are partly the placebo effect and confirmation bias.

    At the risk of being being wrong I am going to say most folks don’t intimately know their own inner workings. They notices some kind of difference.

    I never understood how people can get used to psych meds in their system. I always felt so polluted it drove me crazy.

    If you find the link please remember to post it here.

  5. [...] brain imaging research volunteer [...]

  6. Hi! I just came over from reading your comment on Gianna’s post and was wandering if you could tell me the name of the Chi Gung tapes? You have a very inspirational healing story.

    Thanks
    Tamara

  7. Hi Tamara,

    Thanks for stopping by. I would be happy to share that with you.

    The tape I recommended to Gianna was on the Marriage of Heaven and Earth chi gung.

    There is a few teachers I could recommend but the absolute master of chi gung on the West Coast is a guy I trained with off and on from 1996-2000

    His name is Bruce Frantzis and you can read up on his bio, his teachings and training as well as purchase tapes, videos, Dvds and books as well finding information on his classes, retreats and lectures at this site

    http://www.energyarts.com

    I recommend his chi gung book ‘Opening the Energy Gates of your Body’ ( I bought my first copy of it back in 1990 )

    There is a companion video tape for it.

    He recently published a book on Dragon and Tiger chi gung which was a chi gung system he learned and then practiced in cancer wards in clinics on China

    I also recommend his meditation book Relaxing Into Your Being.

    Practicing his material, the chi gung, the tai chi and meditation saved my life.

  8. Jane,

    Thank you so much. I have already checked out the site and I’ll look at getting the books. I have heard wonderful things about chi gung – just haven’t gotten serious about it. Now is time!

    Tamara

  9. I got an MRI after being drugged and the neurologist told the psychiatrist that he didn’t want to tell her I had slowing in my brain after taking so many drugs because he thought I would sue. Years after the MRI I got tardive dyskinesia. Now that I reduced my drugs from 140 mg to 60mg the tardive dyskinesia and akathisia went away. I am going to reduce my drugs to zero gradually and then go to another neurologist and see what they say about my post td brain. I am doing this without a specialized out of network megabucks psychiatrist and I am not going to pay a therapist anything either. I have helped them make way too much money and they deserve none of it.
    I know where my mental suffering comes from.
    I agree with you that it is not a chemical imbalance.
    If the drugs “fix” a chemical imbalance, why does it cause brain damaging tardive dyskinesia?
    The psychiatrists answer is: “They get it anyway, 15 percent of them were never drugged and they got td.” Psychiatrists would never let a schizophrenic or bipolar they know of get away without being locked up and drugged or given “therapy” no matter how good and innocent they are.
    They are full of lies and the more time mental people spend with them, the worse they get.
    I think there is mental suffering because of injustices that people face. The NIH doctors who post on pubmed.gov all seem to agree that 120 mg of Geodon is the dose that works. That is the dose that caused my tardive dyskinesia.
    It works by clubbing the brain with chemicals until you die from numerous health problems. I have numerous health problems now that I bet other people don’t have because of these so called drugs that fix a so called chemical imbalance.

  10. Dear Linda,

    Thank you for taking the time to share that on this site.

    I always feel pangs of empathy and even pain when I hear about horrible side effect stories. I get close to tears when I hear stories like yours.

    I am in agreement 100% with everything you said.

    There is so much lies, hubris and deception in psychiatry and it’s all fueled by money. A need to get some or a fear of losing it.

    The growing numbers of damaged psych survivors attest to this epidemic of malpractice.

    We must educate each other other alternatives.

    I am very sorry to hear that you too have been damaged by psychiatry. Much worse than I ever was.

    I can only wish you the best and hope for your total recovery.

    For what it’s worth I highly endorse physical-mental-energetic therapies like Yoga, Tai Chi and Chi Gung.

    These will help you rebuild your nerves, your body and help clear mental fog. They can also provide a kind of protective firewall against depression because you will end up generating some neurotransmitters in a natural normal way as you practice.

    Take care for now Linda and thanks for visiting.

  11. Hi Jane,
    I first saw you on u-tube and I am reading your blogs. I have not passed by this issues. Unless I missed it.
    Transcranial magnetic Stimulation
    Vagus Nerve Stimulation
    I am labeled hypomania but I am not sure why. I really only have recurrent untreatable depression. I am interested in meditation. Yet I am a Christian and I was very uncomfortable at the yoga center I went too a few years ago. I am a little to embarassed to go to a Bipolar Depression meeting. Are you involved in any? Also, I live near NYC and I saw some ads. for brain imaging but I never heard back from them. I am going to try again. I am not working and in a depression right now so I guess I would be a good candidate. I am just wondering if you tried TMS or VNS or if you personally know someone and what the results were. Thanks for your site and info. Jane
    Have a nice day

  12. Dear Debra,

    I will be candid. I have not discussed, nor do I have any experience whatsoever with VNS or TMS. I am sorry I can not help you there.

    When you say recurrent, yet untreatable, I am confused.

    It does go away from time to time then comes back. I would be microanalyzing what I was doing every single day and paying attention to what I thinking, feeling and doing on the days that the depression went away on it’s on would be paramount to unraveling the mystery.

    I don’t know you, so I can’t comment on hypomania except to say I think it’s nonsense.

    It was added to make people micro analyze their own behavior and come to the conclusion that their natural impulses or personality quirks were diseases that need treatment. There is no such thing as hypomania in my book.

    As for being Christian and yoga centers and being uncomfortable there?

    Who can say. I am former Christian and my beliefs in the end of the world, in sin, in guilt and fear, in heaven and hell all made me insane over time. In fact my own religious beliefs caused me spiritual depression that never went away until I became agnostic through meditation.

    You have to ask yourself, honestly, in the rhetorical mirror, why did it make you uncomfortable?

    Yoga and meditation are designed to eventually reveal your soul and inner most working to your conscious mind.

    The promise of yoga and meditation is to gain wisdom, strength, insight, morality, understanding, inner peace, inner light, grace, and control over things you may or may not have come to believe are not possible, out of your hands, unnatural, contrary to biblical doctrine or whatever.

    The reason some religions like Christianity look down on or outright forbid learning the occult and relying on mysticism and becoming your own spiritual teacher and master is because well quite frankly, you would no longer be looking for answers, healing, understanding, grace, strength and power from God.

    Perhaps you rightfully sense, that if you open the doors on your heart and mind and spirit you gain knowledge of things and understandings about life different from those that are taught according to catechism.

    Politically speaking, in the old old days of monarchies and despotism, the Church did not want homegrown mystics to come out preaching their own truth and showing their own spiritual light.

    The Church chose Joseph, Moses, John, Paul and Jesus as their mystics and any one else that gains spiritual knowledge or inner power therefore gained it from Satan.

    Maybe I am wrong. I do know if you do meditation and yoga seriously, you will gain *forbidden knowledge* the Bible does not want you to have.

    You also might cure your depressions or other mental illness too instead of relying on God to do it or to teach you humility or some such.

    My own mother is a devout Catholic and she has been her entire life. For over 45 years she has prayed to God and she has suffered recurrent treatment resistant depression her entire life.

    I chose not to wait on the whims of God to be healed. I took my own life and destiny into my own hands rather than placing it in God’s hands and I am wiser, healthier and saner for it.

    The Abrahamic faiths tell you place your faith in and look to a higher power. The Asian mystic traditions teach you to place faith in and look to yourself which amounts to blasphemy or at least heresy.

    Yet it was the Abrahamic faiths that taught me dualism. I was taught I had an immortal soul that would leave my body when I died.

    My question all my life use to be. If I am a soul inhabiting a body, where am I? What good does that knowledge do me? What can I do with my soul while I am still alive? Can I sense my own soul? Use it somehow?

    From there it was a short step to Gnosticism and ontology and that led straight into meditation.

    I am not involved in any Bipolar or depression meetings or groups at this time. As I live on the west coast in the Bay Area I am sure we have a DBSA somewhere but they have not asked me to speak there yet.

    Perhaps I will teach meditation for mental health in the future but not at any time soon.

    Please do not feel I picked on you for being Christian. If you did, such was not the intention.

    Christianity can be a good thing for some people. When I was a kid I thought the world was populated entirely by atheists and Catholics because that was how my parents slanted my education.

    Only when my biological father took me to Hong Kong as a young teen and I stepped foot into a real Buddhist temple did I realize some people had never even heard of Jesus. There were other religions out there that people believed in just as much as my family believed in Christianity.

    Buddhism, Taoism and yoga did not make me feel as helpless, as hopeless, as depressed, as self conscious or as confined as Catholicism.

    Take care, thanks for stopping by and God bless.

  13. [...] help promote Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder drugs, but also medications which help with mental illness. People who are mentally ill are not normal. They are in the minority because it’s well known [...]

  14. One brain researcher I believe in is Matthew Lieberman:

    http://lieber.bol.ucla.edu/Lieberman/lieberman.html

    Maybe you could contact him?


Leave a response

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Categories